"[Claire] Danes, an awkward, clunky film presence...

is an odd choice for the naive, incandescent star. In a not-so-stellar performance, she overacts and struggles with an irritating British accent."

Aside from that, a relatively positive review of Stardust. Curiously, I've read Stardust twice, and both times, within a few months I completely forgot the plot other than it involved some guy wandering in fairyland.